Comedy is Tragedy + Time…. and Twitter

13 Comments »

I did it. Last night I got up on stage and read at Grownups Read Things they Wrote as Kids. I read some poetry I wrote in grade nine about a boy, love, drugs, zits–you name it. Yes, in a narcissistic way, I just want to share it with you because I did something that was a bit outside my comfort zone and I like that.

But, I also want to reflect on the question you might be asking yourself “why (the hell) did I want to read something I wrote in grade 9?”

In fact, I want reflect on why the 11 other people who read last night jumped on stage to read stuff. On a bigger scale, I want to consider why Dan Misener’s project has been so successful that last night was the 10th anniversary of the event.

I think there’s a clue to all of this in Dan’s own description of how the whole thing got started. Apparently he was at his girlfriend’s house for Christmas when the two stumbled on her old diary. They spent the day reading out loud to one another and discovered:

`This is really funny, reading this stuff out loud to each other. I bet other people are in the exact same boat. I bet a lot of other people have this kind of stuff lying around. And wouldn’t it be fun to get together with a bunch of them and do exactly this?’”

When I was searching for the right stuff to read, I didn’t think the poems I selected were funny at all. In fact, I thought they were tragic. When I was listening to other people’s readings, I thought, “theirs are funny, but mine’s not funny.” But, it turns out my poems were funny too.  As you watch the video, pay attention to where the laughter erupts. It’s worth noting.

The question around why people like to share stuff like this is not unlike understanding the psychology of using social media platforms like Twitter.

Some pop-psychology writers like those who are published in Psychology Today have theorized that it’s all about our need to connect with community. A community that has become more and more inaccessible since the Industrial Revolution.

Others like David Lewis, a cognitive psychologist in the UK, claim that it’s all about existentialism:

“Using Twitter suggests a level of insecurity whereby, unless people recognize you, you cease to exist. It may stave off insecurity in the short term, but it won’t cure it.”

As I reflect on the experience of sharing something awkward and painful, I’m reminded of some of my more painful Tweets. I can remember the hellish parenting moment I was having when I Tweeted,

“These kids could lead a person to Nicorette.”

The tragedy of my parenting situation only became funny when I said it out loud–mostly to strangers out there in the Twitter-verse.

At their best, narcissistic Tweets aren’t much different than reading grade 9 poetry to an audience of grownups. Twitter provides a reflective distance that allows one to step outside of a given moment and therefore have a different reaction to one’s circumstances. Maybe that’s one reason why Twitter’s so big among the mommy crowd.

After all, as the queen of comedy Carole Burnett once said, “Comedy is tragedy plus time.” To that I would add, “Comedy is Tragedy plus Twitter.”



  • Sarah

    I LOVE this! I’ve always wanted to go to one of these reading nights. So glad you did.

  • dmisener

    Jodi, thanks so much for reading. You were terrific.

    I think I can offer a little insight into why people want to share this kind of material. In preparation for the radio version of GRTTWaK, I read a book called Yearning for Yesterday by Fred Davis. It came out in 1979, and it’s all about nostalgia and why we feel it, and its role in society. Fred Davis says that one of the functions of nostalgia is that it lets us rediscover our “secret selves.” He says there’s something about the incredibly private that yearns to be made public, and that by sharing our “secret selves and odd tastes” with others… we realize how much more alike than different we actually are.

    He says “At one and the same time, then, our nostaliga for those aspects of our past selves that were ‘odd and different’ becomes the basis for deepening out sentimental ties to others and for reassuring us that we are not _that_ strange after all. Others, it turns out, were equally strange.”

    In other words, through shared nostalgia, we can become normal.

  • Johnstonlerche

    Can’t believe this blog is free. It’s better than …..chocolate! Can’t believe you actually through yourself out there and did this on a Monday night or any other night for that matter.It’s kind of like flashing but legal. You are a cool chick. Jen(market)

  • Patty

    Oh, Jodi, I can relate to that boy.. I love you too, zits and all!

  • Shayma

    I don’t know or care whether this is narcissistic or not- bec I love it- it is heartfelt, and true. and real. x shayma

  • Jodi

    And, do you think that “narcissistic” Tweets have the same effect? Even though the time lapse is much shorter (obviously) there’s the small grain of distance (even a second or two) that makes sharing worthwhile. Is there a parallel there? Davis’ book sounds great. Dan, it was a great event. I didn’t realize how funny it would be. And how cathartic it would be.

    By the way, you have my full permission to use the tagline. But it’s actually with 3 “too tired’s.” Just for the sake of clarity it goes “Too tired, too tired, too tired. Fuck you.”

  • Jodi

    You should. It was incredible. And so funny.

  • Jodi

    You’re pretty swell too. Poor exboyfriend. He’s been more “exposed” than me.

  • http://www.hypenotic.com/ Barry A. Martin

    I can’t wait to show this on “things people did on stage when they were 40″.

    I was in the crowd. You were great. I laughed too, even with the detachment that tends to accompany holding camera. Congrats.

    B

  • http://www.hypenotic.com/ Barry A. Martin

    I can’t wait to show this on “things people did on stage when they were 40″.

    I was in the crowd. You were great. I laughed too, even with the detachment that tends to accompany holding camera. Congrats.

    B

  • dmisener

    Can’t speak to Twitter, but I definitely think the element of distance is important in juvenilia. The distance between “who I was” and “who I am” is what makes these things funny, and sometimes sad.

    Davis talks about nostalgia as a way of creating stories about ourselves, as a way of creating continuity within our self-narratives. I see a certain parallel w/ Twitter there…

  • Pingback: “I could have had at least fifteen poops!” | Little Bites with Bigwood

  • Cheryl

    you are one of my favourite people.

    i will think that even if your zits come back.